Sentinel species

Some animals and plants react to a changing environment sooner, or more visibly, than we do. Watch them closely and they become living instruments: monitors that were running long before anyone wrote a line of code.

$ sentinels ls
NAME        MEDIUM       STATUS
canary      air          retired 1986
amphibians  water, land  in use
lichens     air          in use
bees        land         in use
mussels     water        in use
seabirds    sea          in use
$

What is a sentinel species?

A sentinel species is an organism whose health, behaviour, numbers or chemistry tells us something about the environment it shares with us, ideally before the same change harms people or the wider ecosystem. The idea is simple: let a sensitive living thing take the reading.

early warning

Reacts quickly to a sudden hazard. The classic example is a canary in a coal mine, which showed distress from carbon monoxide well before the miners felt it.

accumulator

Builds up a record over time. Mussels and lichens soak up contaminants from the water or air around them, so their tissues can be analysed like a sample log.

population signal

Shows change through numbers and breeding. Falling frog counts or failed seabird nesting seasons can point to trouble in a whole habitat or food web.

A sentinel is a signal, not a diagnosis. A change tells us where to look; working out the cause still takes careful measurement.

The status board

Six sentinels, each with what it senses, the signal we read from it, why it works and where it falls short. Filter by medium and pick a tile to open its details.

retired 1986Canary in the coal mine

senses: Carbon monoxide underground, especially after fires and explosions.
signal: The bird becomes distressed, sways on its perch or collapses, well before people nearby feel the effects.
why it works: A small body, a fast metabolism and a highly efficient bird lung mean a canary takes up the gas much faster than a person does.
in practice: The physiologist John Scott Haldane proposed carrying small animals into mines in the 1890s, and canaries served in British mines and mine rescue for decades. Some rescue cages even carried a small oxygen supply to revive the bird.
limits: It only shows that something is wrong once the gas is already present, and it cannot say how much. In 1986 British coal mines replaced their canaries with electronic gas detectors.

population signalAmphibians frogs, toads, newts, salamanders

senses: Polluted water and soil, drained or fragmented habitat, disease, and shifts in temperature and rainfall.
signal: Shrinking or vanishing populations, failed breeding, and in some places deformed animals.
why it works: Thin, permeable skin takes in water and oxygen, and whatever is dissolved in them. Most amphibians lead a double life, as eggs and larvae in water and as adults on land, so trouble in either place reaches them. Many have small home ranges and cannot easily move away.
in practice: Long-term pond and road-crossing counts, often run with volunteers. Amphibians are among the most threatened groups of vertebrates, and a fungal disease, chytridiomycosis, has driven severe declines worldwide.
limits: Declines usually have several causes at once, which makes the signal hard to pin on any single problem.

accumulatorLichens on bark, walls and rock

senses: Air pollution: historically sulphur dioxide, and today increasingly nitrogen pollution such as ammonia.
signal: Which species grow where, and how much. Sensitive species disappear first, while nitrogen-loving ones, such as some bright orange lichens, spread.
why it works: A lichen is a partnership between a fungus and algae or cyanobacteria. With no roots, it takes water and nutrients straight from rain and air, absorbing whatever comes with them, and it cannot shed them each autumn the way a tree sheds leaves.
in practice: In the 1860s the botanist William Nylander noticed lichens vanishing from the Luxembourg Garden in Paris and linked it to polluted air. In many European cities lichens have since returned as sulphur dioxide levels fell.
limits: Lichens respond over years rather than hours, and identifying species takes practice.

population signalBees honey bees and wild bees

senses: Pesticides, metals and other contaminants across a landscape, along with the loss of flowers and nesting habitat.
signal: Colony health and losses, residues measured in bees, pollen, wax and honey, and the variety of wild bees that turn up in surveys.
why it works: Foragers visit enormous numbers of flowers over a wide area, honey bees often several kilometres from the hive, and carry samples of that landscape home.
in practice: Researchers analyse hive products for residues, and pollinator surveys track how wild bee communities change with land use. Bee declines are generally linked to a mix of habitat loss, pesticides, parasites and disease, and climate.
limits: Honey bees are managed animals, so beekeeping practice and parasites such as the varroa mite affect colonies too. A struggling hive is not always an environmental signal.

accumulatorMussels coastal and freshwater

senses: Contaminants in coastal and fresh water, such as metals and persistent organic pollutants, and sudden pulses of something toxic.
signal: What builds up in their tissue, how well they grow, and in some set-ups the moment they snap their shells shut.
why it works: Mussels are filter feeders that pump large volumes of water over their gills. They stay in one place, so what they carry reflects that spot, and they are common and easy to collect.
in practice: “Mussel watch” programmes in several countries have sampled mussels and oysters along coastlines since the 1970s and 80s. Some water utilities keep freshwater mussels with sensors on their shells at water intakes: if many close at once, it is a cue to check the water.
limits: How much a mussel accumulates depends on species, season and condition, and reading the record takes laboratory analysis.

population signalSeabirds fulmars, puffins, kittiwakes and more

senses: The state of the ocean food web, contaminants at sea, and floating plastic litter.
signal: Breeding success, what chicks are fed and how well they grow, contaminants in eggs and feathers, and plastic in stomachs.
why it works: Seabirds are predators near the top of the marine food web that forage over wide areas, yet nest in colonies on land where they can be counted year after year.
in practice: Around the North Sea, the plastic found in the stomachs of northern fulmars washed up on beaches is used as an indicator of litter at sea. Breeding failures at some colonies have been linked to shortages of small prey fish such as sandeels.
limits: Colonies respond to many pressures at once, including food, weather, predators and disease, so it takes long records to read a trend.

What makes a good sentinel

No species ticks every box, but the useful ones tick most of these.

sensitive: Reacts to the change at levels, or at a stage, that we would otherwise miss.
measurable: Responds in a way we can read: survival, behaviour, breeding, growth, chemistry, or simply being present or absent.
known_baseline: We know what normal looks like, so a change stands out.
shared_exposure: Meets the hazard the same way we, or the wider ecosystem, would: the same air, water or food.
easy_to_find: Common, widespread and easy to identify, so it can be sampled often without doing harm.
location: fixed species such as lichens and mussels map a reading to one spot; roaming ones such as seabirds and foraging bees sum up a wide area.
memory: instant sentinels like the canary raise the alarm now; cumulative ones like mussels and lichens keep a record you can read later.

Changelog

A few milestones in learning to read living things as signals.

1866added
Lichens. William Nylander links the loss of lichens in Paris’s Luxembourg Garden to polluted air.
1890sadded
Canaries. John Scott Haldane proposes taking small animals into mines to warn of carbon monoxide.
1960sadded
Birds of prey. Researchers connect thinning eggshells in peregrine falcons and other raptors to residues of the pesticide DDT.
1962docs
Silent Spring. Rachel Carson’s book brings the effects of pesticides on birds and other wildlife to a wide audience.
1975added
Mussels. A “mussel watch” is proposed: using mussels and oysters to monitor pollution along coasts.
1986deprecated
Canaries. British coal mines phase out canaries in favour of electronic gas detectors.
todayongoing
Sensors and sentinels together. Lichen surveys track nitrogen pollution, mussels with shell sensors sit at some water intakes, and long-running seabird and amphibian counts keep adding years of data.

Contact the maintainer

Found an error, want to suggest another sentinel, or just want to say hello? Your message goes straight to the person who runs this site.